Root canal or implant: what the studies say and how to decide

Keeping the tooth with a root canal or replacing it with an implant: how long each option lasts according to the studies, and what to ask before deciding.
Dental model showing an implant next to two natural teeth with their roots

Both options work, and they do not compete: a root canal keeps your tooth and an implant replaces it when it can no longer be kept. In the largest study comparing them, 83.4% of root canal treated teeth and 97.9% of implants were still in place at nine years, but the root canal cost less than half.

The useful question is not which is better, but whether your tooth can be saved with a good outlook.

What the largest study measured

A study using Sweden's national registry, published in 2026, compared 10,654 root canal treatments with 5,327 implants in similar patients, followed for up to nine years. The implant lasted longer in almost every area of the mouth and cost more than twice as much. In lower front teeth, the root canal did better and cost less.

It is a registry study, not a trial: patients were not assigned at random, and an implant that is still in place is not always free of problems.

How long a root canal treated tooth lasts

How long an implant lasts

A 2026 review that pooled only studies with at least twenty years of follow-up found that 93% of implants were still in place. The crown on top usually needs repair or replacement sooner, and the gum around an implant needs the same care as the gum around a tooth: daily cleaning and maintenance visits.

How to decide in your case

  • Keeping the tooth usually makes sense when enough healthy tooth remains to place a crown, the root is not fractured, and the gum and bone are in good shape.
  • An implant usually makes sense when the root is fractured, very little tooth remains, or the root canal has already been redone without success.
  • Your health matters: smoking, poorly controlled diabetes and gum problems lower implant results.

Keeping the tooth does not close the door on an implant: if the tooth is lost years later, the implant is still an option. More in root canal treatment and dental implants.

Tip from the PureSmile team

Ask three things before deciding: whether the tooth can be restored with a crown, what happens if you do nothing yet, and what the price of each option includes, in writing.

Signs it is time to book a visit

  • You were told a tooth has to come out and want to know if it can be kept.
  • You have had a root canal without a crown for months.
  • A root canal treated tooth hurts again or a small bump appears on the gum.

How we do it at PureSmile

PureSmile Miami has been seeing patients since November 2, 2026, at 8000 SW 117th Ave, Suite 100, in Kendall. Our dentist examines the tooth and, when needed, studies it with 3D imaging. He explains on screen whether it can be kept and with what outlook, and gives you each option with its price in writing before we start. If you already have a plan from another office, you can bring it for a second opinion.

Book your visit or call us at (305) 787-3642.

Related guides

Frequently asked questions

Which is better, a root canal or an implant?

It depends on whether the tooth can be restored. If it can, keeping it costs less and leaves the implant as an option for later. If it cannot, the implant is the alternative with the most support.

How long does a root canal treated tooth last?

In US data, 86% are still in place at ten years. With a crown it lasts longer.

Do I need a crown after a root canal?

On back teeth, almost always. Studies show teeth with a crown last longer.

General information; not a substitute for an in-person evaluation. Sources: Mota de Almeida, J Dent (2026); Burry, J Endod (2016); Thyvalikakath, J Dent Res (2022); Aquilino, J Prosthet Dent (2002); Lupi, Int J Oral Maxillofac Surg (2026). Yoan Suárez Zayas, DMD · FL Lic. DN 21413.

Otros artículos

Ver todos
November 12, 2026